Nuisance Points, Police Calls and Crime Data: The Public Records That Can Prove a Wilmington Property Owner Saw Danger Coming

A negligent-security case usually rises or falls on one question: did the owner have reason to expect trouble? In Delaware, judges answer it by examining everything that had gone wrong at and around the location, not just whether the identical crime happened before. That makes records of past problems at a Wilmington address some of the most valuable evidence a victim can have.

Fortunately, much of that history is documented, and some of it is public.

Wilmington's Public Nuisance Properties program

The City of Wilmington has run a Public Nuisance Properties program since 2009. Under a city ordinance adopted that year, properties accumulate points based on nuisance calls and code violations, and the city can designate a location as a public nuisance once it crosses certain thresholds. The program can apply to rental housing, owner-occupied homes, and licensed businesses, and owners, landlords, and those in control of the property can be held responsible.

For a negligent-security claim, the significance is straightforward. If a property was flagged, warned, or penalized under the program before an attack, that is strong evidence its owner knew about recurring problems. Even short of a formal designation, the underlying calls and violations can help establish a pattern.

State criminal nuisance enforcement

Separately, the Delaware Department of Justice has used a criminal nuisance abatement statute to pursue properties tied to repeated drug activity, shootings, and other serious crime. Enforcement actions, warning letters, and settlements under that program can also show that an owner had notice of serious danger at a location.

Police calls for service

Every call to the Wilmington Police Department generates a record, whether it involves a fight, a robbery, shots fired, a burglary, or a disturbance. Collected for a specific address over several years, those calls can paint a detailed picture of what an owner was dealing with. Because Delaware recognizes that lesser incidents can make violent crime foreseeable, a long list of thefts, trespassing complaints, and disturbances may be just as important as earlier shootings.

Citywide trends: helpful context, not the whole story

The Wilmington Police Department publishes annual year-end reports. Its 2025 report showed shooting incidents falling 21 percent from the prior year, to 64, the lowest total since 2003, with murders down 20 percent. Local reporting during 2026 has noted periods of renewed violence even as longer-term trends improved.

Those numbers are useful background, but defendants sometimes point to falling citywide crime to argue that an attack was unexpected. That argument misses the point. Under Delaware law, the question is what the specific owner knew about its specific property, and a location with persistent problems can remain dangerous even when the city as a whole improves.

Records from the property itself

Public records are only part of the picture. Lawyers also seek the owner's own documents:

  • Incident reports written by managers or security staff
  • Tenant and customer complaints about crime or broken security features
  • Work orders for locks, gates, lights, and cameras
  • Emails discussing crime, security budgets, or guard staffing
  • Contracts with security companies and their patrol logs
  • Insurance claims and prior lawsuits involving crimes at the location

When these internal records line up with police calls and nuisance-program history, the owner's knowledge can become very difficult to dispute.

Getting the records before they disappear

Some public records can be requested relatively easily. Others, along with the property's own files and video, require formal discovery after a lawsuit is filed. Surveillance footage in particular may be overwritten within days. A lawyer can send prompt preservation letters and use public-records requests to begin building a timeline right away.

Connecting knowledge to failure

Proving the owner knew about danger is the first step. From there, a plaintiff has to demonstrate an inadequate response, for instance unrepaired entry doors, guard positions cut, or drug dealing left alone, and tie that shortfall to the shooting or stabbing. Delaware's comparative fault rules and the absence of a general damages cap for ordinary negligence will then shape the recovery.

About the firm and Delaware representation

The Haggard Law Firm, a Coral Gables firm focused on crime victims, is led by Michael A. Haggard, who holds a Florida license and is not admitted in Delaware. On Wilmington claims he is co-counsel to a Delaware-licensed attorney and, where the court allows, requests pro hac vice standing for that particular case.

About 500 negligent-security claims make up the firm's track record, one of which yielded a $102.7 million verdict, still the record for a U.S. negligent-security jury; that amount is gross.

Legal fees arise only when money is won for the client. Confidential evaluations are free by phone at (305) 446-5700 or visit https://crimevictim.attorney/negligent-security/delaware/wilmington/.

Attorney advertising. Descriptions of city and state programs are general and may change; this post does not offer legal advice. Contacting the firm is not, by that act alone, retaining it. Mr. Haggard is licensed in Florida. Earlier verdicts promise nothing about future ones.